Marvel's Daredevil has what Gotham Wants

Before I begin, let me just say that when it comes to the whole Marvel vs DC debate, I fall on neither side, and I fall on both sides. To me, they are all characters that I enjoy and I am not turned off by the comics label I see in the credits. That being said, let's talk about Marvel's latest offering, Daredevil on Netflix.

It's the show we deserve, but not the show we need... Pretty sure neither of that is true

Actually, let's compare it to the other comic book show that I was excited for until recently, Gotham. Being blunt, I am really dissappointed by Gotham. The characters are really one noted, and in some cases more cartoony than the animated counterpart, the story is dull, and it irritates me how it can never decide what it wants to be. I just want to shake it and ask it if it wants to be more like the Burton version of Batman, or the Nolan version of Batman. Either way, I will like whichever way they choose because I like both of those approaches, but when they swing back and forth week after week, it gets kind of irritating. On top of that, they are focusing too much on characters that we have seen a million times already, while completely forgetting about characters that haven't gotten that much attention in the past, that would be perfect for this show. Yeah, seeing awkward geeky Riddler is fun, and emo, possibly gay Penguin is a scene-stealer, but when are we gonna get Dr. Hugo Strange? And I swear to God, I will protest this show if I never hear anything to do with Black Mask.


                                                 
Seriously, less Jada Pinkett Smith, more of these two. I'll settle for any of these two, in exchange for zero Jada Pinkett Smith

Daredevil, on the other hand is a freaking masterpiece. While Gotham clutters its show with tons of characters that are all underdeveloped, Daredevil keeps the main cast tidy and gives each character (and the actor's playing them) time to shine. While Gotham is a real show that makes its characters feel very comic-book-ey, Daredevil is also a real show and makes its characters feel real. They don't feel like characters pulled from the panels of comics, they feel like real people. What Gotham is really missing is a strong central villain to drive the action of the overall story (again I bring up Black Mask). What Gotham needs is a character like Wesley's employer (we don't say his name), who should feel very cartoony, but actor Vincent D'onofrio plays him in a manner you wouldn't come to expect from a continuity that includes The Red Skull. His characteristics don't come across like they are a personality quirk or a disorder, as tends to be the case with a number of big screen villains, they come across as feeling like real characteristics of people we meet. He has anger issues, we all know someone like that. He's awkward when he is in public, we all have a friend like that. The most sympathetic aspect of his character is that he honest to God, hand over his heart believes that the horrible things he is doing are all for the benefit of his city, or at least will be in the long run. If I had to compare him to another on screen villain, it would be Anton from No Country for Old Men. He takes no real pleasure in doing what he does, but if he doesn't do them, then the world will be thrown off. Characters like that fascinate me, and in a world where we have embraced the villain who feels fully justified even when they are spreading misery and chaos (Red Skull, Loki), it's refreshing to have a character that actually admits "yeah, I've done and will do unforgivable things, and I hate that."

On top of that, his assistant, Wesley is a rather underrated highlight of the show. Where in the comics, he was just Kingpin's sniveling number 2, in the show, he is written as being the Kobayashi to Fisk's Keyser Soze. He's that asshole who you want to hate, but the actor plays him with such a supreme level of confidence and he is truly the best at what he does that he ends up being that villain you hate to love.

Okay, so I've touched on the villains quite a bit, and while I could probably write a whole essay on why I love these characters, there are other characters in the show that I like. Actually, all the characters in the show I like. That's the benefit of keeping your cast clutter free. And there are layers to each character. Sure, Matt's partner Foggy makes a ton of wisecracks, but the two have great chemistry, and it is also made clear that, for as much as Foggy moans about the path they chose vs the path they were offered, he believes that what he is doing is the right thing. Perhaps taking the prestigious job where they interned was the wiser option, but actually representing people in need is ultimately what helps him sleep at night, even if it doesn't always help pay the bills. At least at first.

See what I mean about these people feeling real and having some depth? And that's really what you want most in a tv show where the focus and what draws people to watching it is the characters. And the stronger the characters and relationships are, the more we believe in their emotional conflicts and sympathize with their struggles. The characters and stories in Gotham feel very cartoony and don't take a lot of risks, so we know that in the end, it's going to be alright, and that saps out all of the suspense. Daredevil sees its main character get in a brawl and get the crap kicked out of him almost every episode, and when we see him bruised, bloody, broken, almost die and still wanting to get up for the next round, that's just empowering. Especially when you consider he is blind.

Gotham, learn to take risks. Don't be afraid to drag your characters through hell. That idea may make writers shift a little, but the show will leave a bigger impression on people if you do.